Stenciling Existing Concrete

Adding pattern to concrete through the use of stencils was one of the earliest applications of decorative concrete. It is also the subject of some of the newest technology in the decorative field today. There are three distinct methods for adding stenciled designs to existing concrete: sandblasting, topping with an overlayment, and modifying the surface with gelled acid etching. All rely on stencils to mask certain areas and expose others to create a design, but beyond that commonality all three techniques are very different in both application and result.

Gaye Goodman used staining, Flattooing and etching techniques to create a floor perfectly suited for the Hot Air Balloon Museum in Albuquerque, N.M.

Sandblasting
Sandblasting is one of the oldest techniques for etching patterns into stone, wood, metal, and, of course, concrete. This technique removes the top surface of the cured concrete that is not masked by the stencil, leaving behind a raised pattern.

Sandblasting is truly a one-of-a-kind technique for high-end decorative concrete. While the designs can be and often are very contemporary, the technique has a traditional, historic, “carved-in-stone” feel about it. Since sandblasting is an elaborate, relatively expensive procedure, sandblasted designs usually cover a fairly small area and are almost always custom projects. “It is a way to get something unique,” says Lee Russell, foreman with Lowell Russell Concrete Inc., in Lakeville, Minn. Designs range from family crests on patios, pool decks, even the bottom of swimming pools, to company logos and graphics.

To get started with sandblasting, you’ll need a sandblasting tank and an air compressor. You’ll also need a lot of safety equipment, Russell says, including an air-fed helmet mask that pumps breathable air, and various sizes of nozzles so you can adjust how much sand comes through.

Graphic artist Tamryn Doolan of Surface Gel-Tek recreated a custom Flattoo of an antique alimeter (labeled in French) for artist Gaye Goodman, owner of Faux Real Floors of Albuquerque, N.M. Goodman was commissioned as the decorative concrete contractor for the Hot Air Balloon Museum in Albuquerque.

Typically, the nozzle is directed straight down, shooting sand with pressure sufficient to remove the surface of the concrete. The nozzle must keep moving to avoid creating pits or deeper impressions in one spot. Another approach is “shading” — shooting the sand at an angle to create a more dimensional, asymmetrical look.

Of course, “you end up with sand all over the place,” Russell says. He directs sand to a central spot for collection with a backpack blower and then rinses off what is left. For obvious reasons, this technique is more often used outdoors and not often for rehabbing interior spaces.

The concrete mix and finish have an impact on the appearance of the finished project. “I try to get in on the project from the very get-go,” says Clark Paepke, a contractor and international concrete consultant based in Sandy, Utah. “I enjoy that more because I know the personality of the concrete and how to finish it.” For example, if an acid stain will be applied before sandblasting, the concrete needs a tight finish.

Grit and pressure also determine the finished look. “If you use a 50-90 grit you can get a glassy look. Heavier sand exposes more aggregate,” Paepke says. Lowell says abrasive blasting crystals, which are sharper and harder than typical silica sand, may be needed on concrete with a harder finish or if a more aggressive aggregate exposure is desired.

So, what about the creative side of sandblasting — the stencil? “This is the cool thing about sandblasting — there are no design limitations,” says Glen Roman of Brickform Products. “You can get very fine detail sandblasting with a stencil.”

Stencils must stand up to pressure from the air hose, so they are typically cut from vinyl rather than paper. “Vinyl can be easily adhered in most cases and allows for more detail-oriented designs,” says Heather Monroe, senior operations manager for Decorative Concrete Impressions LLC, in Webb City, Mo. “Vinyl also provides an increased physical durability for the sandblasting process. We manufacture stencils from 25 mil vinyl.” She cautions, however, that vinyl does stretch. “It must be handled carefully to avoid distortion to the material.”

Melanie Royals of Modello Designs recommends a stencil at least 10 mil thick for light sandblasting and says, “Deeper carving will require 25-mil green rubber.” Brickform makes custom stencils out of 40-mil latex rubber.

Adhesive is important to keep the edges from curling (so sand doesn’t infiltrate the design area). Brickform’s Roman recommends using adhesive-backed stencils rather than spraying adhesive on at the site, which can damage the stencil or compromise sealer performance. If a custom design is large enough to require more than one stencil, they typically do not overlap. Lowell recommends butting the stencils up to each other and attaching them with tape.

Overlayments
Stenciling with cementitious toppings can produce a very different look from sandblasting and is particularly well suited to rehabilitating worn or discolored concrete. A stencil is placed over existing concrete, often over a base coat, and then a topping in a different color is sprayed or troweled over the stencil and finished. The result is a clean, fresh-looking pattern with a very tough, durable surface.

Stenciled cementitious toppings are most often used for repeated patterns such as brick, cobbles or stones for borders, pathways, driveways, patios and pool decks, to name a few applications. The most popular and successful patterns are “right angles” — bricks or cobblestones, most experts agree, whereas patterns intended to mimic natural stone are more convincing in stamped concrete.

When putting down an overlayment, the concrete underneath should be rough enough to provide “teeth” for a mechanical bond between surface and topping. Scott Thome, director of product services at L.M. Scofield Co., references the International Concrete Repair Institute (ICRI) SCP 3-5 standard. “This involves mechanical means of preparation,” he says. “Sandblasting, shot blasting, high-pressure water (4,000 psi or greater) or light scarification creates a surface that the topping can bond to.”

The concrete for this crest was colored cream beige with a color hardener, then stained black. A stencil was applied and the exposed black was sandblasted away, leaving only the black outline and accents. The sand-blasted areas were then stained by hand to achieve the variation of colors.

An existing slab can also be profiled with a gelled acid applied according to ASTM Standard D-4260. Profiling acid etches the concrete to create a rough surface. Tamryn Doolan, president and CEO of Surface Gel Tek, was a co-author of this standard. She says etching costs roughly 12 cents to 15 cents per square foot, compared to as much as $1.25 for mechanical surface opening.

When preparing the substrate, spalls and cracks must be addressed. Spalls should be filled prior to priming with a compatible repair material. If the cracks are dynamic (moving), they must be allowed to move and therefore be reflected through the system. “Remember, not all concrete can be repaired,” Thome says. “Sometime it is better to rip out and replace than to place a topping to try to cover up defects. The first thing that should be done on all of these projects is determine if the substrate is sound and durable and will meet the intent of the owner for a long service life.”

Logos are popular designs for stenciling projects, like this one created by Decorative Concrete Impressions.

Once the substrate passes muster, the next step is to install a bond coat. The bond coat is typically a fluid cementitious material (sometimes a dilute version of the topping material) and acts as a primer. It can be sprayed on, but Thome recommends working the material into the substrate with a broom after spraying to minimize moisture loss and to fill small pinholes in the substrate that might telescope to the surface.

The overlayment is applied over the bond coat. Thome recommends finishing the first coat with a trowel to force the material into the concrete substrate. This improves bond strength and fills in imperfections in the concrete. This underlying layer is the color and material that will be exposed when the stencil is removed. In most patterns, it will have the appearance of grout lines.

Next, the stencil is applied. You don’t need a stencil that has an adhesive backing if the overlay will be spray-applied, says Howard Jancy, business development manager for Butterfield Color. He does recommend using an adhesive stencil to avoid stencil movement if you plan to trowel, and also for vertical applications. According to Brad Berg, vice president of Architectural Enhancements in Minnesota, stencils manufactured with an adhesive backing are better suited for more intricate designs.

If more than one stencil is required, the second one should overlap the first at a grout line to keep these lines uniform.

The top layer, in a different color, is sprayed or troweled over the stencil. Spraying leaves a “sandy” finish that increases skid resistance. Alternatively, the high points can be knocked down with a trowel to leave small smooth areas on the top surface for better walking comfort while leaving enough texture to avoid slipperiness in wet areas. This finish looks similar to a spatter finish on a vertical surface.

Troweling the top layer delivers a smooth, flat look. Berg takes troweling a step further by suggesting pulling up on the trowel so the suction “drags” the material along the surface to create the uneven look of slate.

A stencil should be lifted as soon as the sprayed material on it dries solid enough to crack but is still somewhat moist. This will prevent pulling the topping and leaving the edges of the pattern ragged.

Modello Designs makes adhesive-backed masking patterns in artistic designs such as vines, medallions and geometric patterns that are well suited for creating raised designs and patterns on concrete — a process they call “embossing” — with troweled and sprayed overlayments. The overlayment is troweled or sprayed through the Modello pattern in a thin layer — just thick enough to raise a textured design. While many overlayment systems will perform well for this process, Modello Designs has worked closely with various companies and their product lines to develop processes for achieving optimum and durable results, including Colormaker’s Sgraffino, Concrete Solution’s Spray Top and Skimstone’s integrally colored hybridized portland cement.

Gelled acid etching
The artistic limits of stenciled concrete are being challenged by new acid-etching technology. In this case a vinyl stencil is applied to unsealed, clean, dry, grease-free concrete and a gelled acid is brushed on with a nonmetallic, acid-resistant brush. The acid reacts with the lime, calcium and salts in the concrete. The material is left on for five to 15 minutes until desired etch is achieved. Until the stencil is removed, the acid may be reapplied if adequate etching was not achieved the first time. A power supply on the job site is not required for this stenciling method.

The stencil is left in place while the material is removed with a wet cloth or plastic or rubber trowel, such as a wallpaper smoother. Any material left behind is neutralized with a water rinse and then a second clean water rinse finishes the process. Gelled acid neutralized with water can be flushed into the sewer.

The stencil can be removed immediately or sections of it “weeded” so additional colors can be applied (see “Placing Stencils” sidebar). The top surface of the concrete areas that are exposed to the acid is removed. The result is a textured, slip-resistant surface. Contractors can control the level of the etching by selecting a more or less aggressive gelled acid product and monitoring how long they leave it on.

Doolan of Surface Gel Tek (the original manufacturer of gelled acid) says she spent so much time explaining the difference between this process and sandblast stenciling that she dropped the word “stencil” and coined the term “Flattoo” to avoid confusion. Gel Tek’s Flattoo stock patterns include a variety of borders, animals, petroglyphs, and plants. Doolan says 70 percent of the Flattoos Gel Tek supplies are custom. “This method delivers a dramatic stained look with unlimited graphic possibilities.”

According to Royals of Modello Designs, there are many variations to using the simple gelled acid technique to achieve different looks on cementitious overlays as well as directly on concrete. Royals adds interest to plain borders around her company’s intricate designs by dipping a piece of 1 mil plastic, such as a grocery bag, into a plate of gelled acid and then dabbing it onto the concrete in a staccato up-and-down motion. The result is a stippled, textured-looking effect that can be enhanced by adding colored stain. She also varies the intensity of the etching by sponging the company’s DesignEtch material through the design area and removing it almost immediately with a soft trowel. She then adds more color back into the etched area with acid or water-based stains thickened with a gel.

Conclusion
So how does one choose the right system for a stenciling project? “This really depends on the design or texture the owners want,” Thome says. “All of these systems have their place in the decorative concrete market but not one can do it all. The glory of these systems is that most of them can be used in conjunction with others. This versatility enables the contractor to be extremely creative and perform at a high level of craftsmanship.”

Modello Dye Stains are available in 24 colors including metallics like the Copper used on this Eastern Medallion. To achieve this depth of color and shine, the Copper Stain Concentrate was only slightly thinned and two layers were applied with a stencil brush. This exotic floor treatment uses a combination of acid stains and Modello Dye Stains. While acid stains are ideal for creating organic effects with more neutral colors, the Modello Dye Stains allow for the incorporation of more dramatic color — in this instance, the red and green areas where the stains were applied in thin layers to create a translucent effect. Coloring Techniques for Stenciled Concrete Stenciling and coloring go hand-in-hand to create works of art in concrete. Acid- or water-based stains are the most widely used — and most versatile — materials for coloring stenciled projects. Acid stains tend to produce muted, earthy colors, while water-based stains are available in brighter, more vibrant colors. Perhaps the simplest coloring technique is to apply stain to the concrete, apply a stencil and then sandblast or etch away the exposed surface, including the stain. In the finished project, the stained color will remain in the pattern protected by the stencil, while the background will be the original color of the concrete and any aggregate exposed during the process. The mirror image to that technique is to create a resist. Apply the stencil. Then apply a sealer to the exposed areas, whether sandblasted, etched or plain finished concrete or overlay. Remove the stencil and apply the stain. Only the unsealed areas, the pattern of the stencil, will be colored. Melanie Royals of Modello Designs also uses adhesive-backed Modellos to create resist patterns. The design area can be left untouched or colored with acid or water-based dyes. The area is then sealed with a concrete sealer before removing the Modello pattern. After removal the surrounding area can be acid-stained. The sealed areas of the design resist the stain, resulting in a lighter-colored design on a darker field. The technique looks complicated, but the effect is actually quite easy to achieve. Modello Dye Stains were sprayed to color the orange/ochre background after which a Modello border design was applied and “embossed” by spraying through the design and center area with Concrete Solutions’ Spray Top, a sprayable overlayment. The green dye stain colors were then applied over the Spray Top area. Then the Modello pattern was removed to reveal the original stain color below.   Modello Dye Stains were applied by spray, brush and sponge to complete the look of copper wrought iron through a Modello Design on a concrete overlayment surface. Multiple colors of stain may be added to various parts of the design. Keep in mind, though, that liquid colors may migrate. Porous concrete can wick the liquid, drawing it under the stencil. The solution is to use a gelling agent such as Stain Mule stain carrier from Surface Gel Tek or Modello Gel-lo from Modello Designs. Aqueous gels can carry acid-based, water-based and powdered coloring agents. Once the color is neutralized according to the manufacturer’s instructions, the gel can be rinsed off. Contractors can apply many colors to a single stencil by “weeding” the stencil. Tamyrn Doolan of Surface Gel Tek explains, “I cut the whole design into the stencil, but only punch out the parts of the pattern that will be, for example, blue. I apply the blue and then move on to other colors in order.” Doolan applies a temporary sealer to previously colored sections to prevent mixing colors. Royals sometimes sprays a diluted stain over a finished project where a border has been etched with gelled acid. The stain settles into the deeper areas of the etch to add more color there. Contrasting colored overlays are achieved by applying the base coat in one color, placing the stencil and applying the top coat in another color. Stains can also be used. For example, applying a stain by hand to random stones or bricks in the pattern makes it look more natural and more interesting. Grout lines are also enhanced by the addition of stain. Brickform’s Glen Roman described an interesting coloring technique to be used on fresh concrete or an overlay of 1⁄4 inch or more. After the stencil is placed, throw on a dry-shake color hardener and float it in. Then run a texture roller over the top of the stencil and push it into the surface. When the stencil is lifted, the texture will be visible. Finally, sealers impact the look of the colored project. Utah contractor Clark Paepke heightens contrasts by staining the concrete and sealing it with a high-gloss sealer before sandblasting. After the sealer and stain are blasted off the exposed areas, he reseals them with a matte sealer so the glossy logo stands out even more.