Q: What is tungsten carbide?
A: It’s a compound of different materials that starts in powder form. It’s formulated to take a solid shape and can be used in a number of different products. In the power tool industry, it’s used in accessories as a drill bit tip or on the cutting edge or a blade. Primary attributes of tungsten carbide are robustness and life in harsh applications like drilling in hard aggregate.
Q: What drives the universal acceptance of carbide in concrete applications?
A: The perception in the industry is that a product with carbide on it is a better-performing product. For example, a circular saw blade with standard steel teeth versus a blade with carbide teeth, performance goes up dramatically with the carbide blade. The same goes for other cutting accessories: oscillating blades, jig saw blades and reciprocating saw blades.
In the concrete industry, carbide is the standard for drilling holes in concrete and masonry because the material offers the robustness to last for a long period of time. Carbide has become a broad term in the industry, but users know that not all carbide is the same. Users may not know the why of carbide differentiators, but they know the results.
Carbide is different from the steel that makes up the rest of the drill bit. Whether it’s a standard concrete drill bit that goes into a three-jaw chuck tool or an SDS-plus bit or SDS-max bit, the shank is a solid-body piece of steel that’s fluted to ensure material removal. At the tip of that drill bit, the contact point with the work, is some form for carbide.
Q: What can you say about the various bit designs that incorporate carbide?
A: The most common design in concrete drill bits is the two-cutter, although most users wouldn’t refer to it that way. They just know the bit by the two cutting edges on the end of the bit tip. The standard manufacturing process is milling out the steel at the end and attaching a carbide chip, with two edges, using a welding or braising process that connects the carbide to the steel. This is a process known in the concrete industry as embedded carbide.
The next iteration of concrete bit design is the four cutter. In this design, two additional notches are made in the steel on either side of the original carbide chip. New designs have one piece of carbide notched into the steel bit in the shape of the four-cutter. Users may not understand the intricacies of two-cutter versus four-cutter design, but they do know that more carbide at the end of the bit represents a better, longer-lasting concrete drill bit.
Q: Isn’t there a third option?
A: Full-head carbide is not notched pieces set into the steel shaft, but a 100 percent carbide tip that’s interwoven with the steel to create a stronger bond. This is the most robust, longest-lasting design when drilling into hard aggregate or concrete with rebar. There’s a visual difference between the three options.
Some manufacturers are adding more teeth or cutting edges to the carbide head design instead of making a more solid piece because it is difficult to do correctly. Some concrete drill bits have six or more cutting edges now. This tends to be an aesthetic option versus an extreme performance jump.
Q: How does the user know what grade of carbide they’re using?
A: Sub-par carbide breaks apart and can be brittle. Poor carbide can chip or if the welding or braising process is poor, the entire bit head can break off, pop off or twist off. Users can see the difference in performance.
Also, every design in concrete drilling has its weak points. The two-cutter design is fast in concrete drilling, but it doesn’t withstand hitting rebar well. The four-cutter design withstands rebar hits better, but it doesn’t have the life of full-head carbide. The best concrete drill bits in the world feature full-head carbide in SDS-plus or SDS-max configurations. A two-cutter bit is not intended to drill into rebar.
Q: There’s a cost consideration in these bits. How do users justify a more expensive bit?
A: The number one cost on any jobsite is labor. When the workers can’t work because of equipment failure and the need to change a bit, that’s downtime. Worse yet, if there’s no replacement available and workers need to walk the site looking for a replacement bit it’s a waste of money. If there are no replacements work simply stops.
If the user has a bit with five times longer life and workers can stay at the task longer, that’s a big savings. It’s less downtime. Also, workers sometimes can be placed in difficult and strain-inducing positions to drill holes for anchors in concrete. Rotary hammers used for these tasks are powerful and sometimes heavy, plus there’s extreme heat or cold weather. The sooner the worker can complete the job successfully in these difficult conditions the better off that worker will be and the more exacting the work. Breaking a drill bit when hitting rebar or simply wearing out an inferior drill bit prolongs the difficult task.
Q: Do concrete bits have any role in user safety?
A: Recently, users saw a demonstration of what happens when a two-cutter bit hits rebar in concrete. That’s dangerous because the tool can jam and wrench the user’s arm. Bosch has Kickback Control technology in its tools to stop the tool to help prevent injury to the user. Or there’s this option: A four-cutter bit will not bind when it hits rebar.
The four-cutter design doesn’t lock on rebar the way a two-cutter can. This helps prevent injury, but then the bit can suffer failure with a broken head or the cutters become unusable. Then you’re out $80. By contrast, a full-head carbide bit would just drill through the rebar and keep going. The other option is to change to a rebar cutter bit, drill through the rebar and then go back to the concrete bit.
Q: How would you summarize what concrete pros need to know about carbide?
A: Users know some basics about carbide, but their overriding expectation is that more carbide equals a better bit. They’re not wrong. Users just want to know the bit works. They don’t want the carbide to chip or the head to break off. It’s a show-me thing and users will be happy if: Heat won’t kill the bit, rebar won’t break it and hard aggregate won’t wear it down.