The Illusion of Strength
Concrete has long been the symbol of durability — an unyielding surface beneath our feet, our buildings, and our infrastructure. To most, its strength seems obvious and dependable, but in reality the concrete we build with today is not the same as the concrete of a generation ago. Beneath its surface lies a shifting set of variables that can quietly sabotage coatings, sealers, overlays, and other finish systems — often years after installation.
The crazy thing is that failures don’t typically appear overnight. They emerge slowly, revealed by discoloration, delamination, or deterioration long after a project has been signed off. Understanding why this happens — and how to prevent it — is essential for anyone involved in specifying or installing systems over concrete.
 |
 |
The New Concrete: Same Material, New Risks
Concrete today is more engineered than ever before — and that’s both a strength and a liability. The material has evolved from a basic mix of cement, water, and aggregates into a highly customized blend of chemical and mineral components, each with its own purpose and consequence.
“Concrete mix design has evolved from simple, empirical approaches to a science-based discipline that allows for precise control over properties and performance. What was once a learned tradition passed on by tradesmen is now an academic study that requires blended cements and admixtures to produce high performance and self consolidating mixes, while at the same time seeking to satisfy sustainability requirements.” — Matthew Casto
 |
 |
Blended Cements and SCMs
Modern concrete frequently incorporates supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) such as fly ash, slag, and silica fume. These byproducts improve strength and durability, while promoting sustainability — but they also add complexity for decorative finishing.
“During my years working with Boral Industries, I gained firsthand insight into both the benefits and the challenges of integrating SCMs. I learned that most SCMs impact color, workability, and initial set times in an adverse way; some of these materials even increase the risk of plastic shrinkage cracking during the curing process. While these risks are real, so are the benefits of increased strength and durability. Most concrete today utilize SCMs to aid in performance and to control overall costs.” – Matthew Casto
Admixtures: Chemical Control in a Bag
Today’s concrete relies heavily on admixtures to assure performance. Most specifiers and contractors are familiar with chemical water reducers that control water requirements during mixing and lead to enhanced strength and workability, accelerators that speed up set times for fast-track projects, and retarders that delay setting in hot weather or large pours. But newer technologies like nano-silica additives that help manage rapid evaporation and mitigate shrinkage are less understood and are not commonplace.
Nano-silica additives in concrete floors enhance durability, strength, and resistance to chemical and physical attacks. They also improve workability, reduce cracking/curling, eliminate the need for wet curing, and potentially lower the carbon footprint of concrete construction. The fine particles of nano-silica fill voids in the concrete matrix, leading to a denser, more durable structure. Nano-silica enhances compressive, flexural, and tensile strength, making concrete floors more resistant to cracking and damage. The fine particles of nano-silica fill pores and micro-cracks, reducing the permeability of the concrete and making it more resistant to water and chemical penetration.
 |
 |
High-Performance and Specialized Concrete
From self-consolidating concrete (SSC) that flows into complex forms to porous pavement that allow for stormwater infiltration, modern concrete is engineered for function — yet often at the cost of finishability and aesthetic beauty. Self-compacting concrete (SCC) is a special type of concrete that can flow and consolidate under its own weight, without the need for external vibration or compaction. This unique property makes it ideal for filling complex forms and intricate reinforcement layouts, ensuring a dense, uniform, and void-free structure. SCC typically contains a higher proportion of fine aggregates and powder content compared to conventional concrete, requiring super plasticizers and viscosity-modifying admixtures.
Conversely, porous pavement, also known as permeable pavement, is a type of pavement that allows water to pass through it. This allows stormwater to drain into the ground below, reducing runoff and potentially filtering out pollutants. Porous pavement is made with a high percentage of air voids, achieved by removing fine aggregates from the mix and stabilizing with chemical admixtures. Porous pavements recharges groundwater, reduces heat island effect, and reduces the need for other stormwater management infrastructure:
While at Bomanite, Matthew helped develop Grasscrete, a load-bearing, permeable solution for functional design: blending performance with environmental goals without a primary focus on aesthetic value.
 |
 |
Sustainability & Controversy
In the past few years, there has been an increased pressure on the concrete industry to lower its carbon footprint. This has led to innovations like Type 1L limestone-blended cement. The adoption of type 1L Cement has raised concerns from industry stakeholders. Discussions have centered on the impacts of surface performance and long term durability, specifically, lower strength gain, higher water demand, increased cracking, surface imperfections like pinholes and crusting, and potential for discoloration and blotchiness. The introduction of Type 1L Cement is forcing specifiers and installers to adapt quickly — often without clear guidance.
“Change creates opportunity. The widespread adoption of Type 1L will challenge us — but it will also drive revolutionary ideas and new technologies.” – Matthew Casto
Hidden Vulnerabilities: What You Can’t See Will Hurt You
1. Absorption & Porosity
While a concrete slab may look solid and smooth, its internal porosity plays a critical role in how coatings, stains, and overlays behave. Slabs that are too absorptive or inconsistently porous can cause discoloration, patchy coverage, and bond failure. High-performance systems rely on predictable absorption — and too often, it’s left unmeasured.
 |
 |
2. Alkalinity & pH Drift
Concrete starts life with an extremely high pH (typically 12–13). Over time, carbon dioxide exposure causes that number to drift downward — but not always uniformly. A slab may appear cured but still harbor alkalinity levels that disrupt chemical bonds with adhesives or resinous systems. Without testing, you’re working blind.
3. Moisture Movement
Concrete never really stops interacting with moisture. Vapor transmission, capillary action, and hydrostatic pressure can all cause finish failures — especially in sealed systems. Osmotic blistering, efflorescence, or adhesive breakdown may not show up for months or years, making vapor mitigation and moisture testing essential.
 |
 |
4. Rigidity & Shrinkage
Modern concrete can be more rigid than mixes from previous decades. These characteristics are influenced by changes in cement fineness, shortened construction schedules, environmental exposure, and curing practices. While these changes often improve strength or sustainability, they can also increase the risk of surface failure if not carefully managed. Specifically, modern cements are typically ground more finely than older formulations. This increases surface area, which enhances reactivity and strength — but also raises the mix’s water demand. More water means more potential for shrinkage as excess moisture evaporates during curing. Furthermore, to meet fast-track schedules, many concrete mixes are engineered for rapid hydration and early strength gain. While this improves construction efficiency, it can cause more aggressive volume change (shrinkage) during the early curing phase, particularly if curing is rushed or inconsistent.
 |
 |
What Lies Beneath Is Only the Beginning
Today’s concrete may appear durable on the surface, but hidden variables — from chemistry to climate — can quietly undermine even the best designs. The first step to preventing failure is understanding that not all slabs are created equal. But knowledge alone isn’t enough.
In Part 2, we’ll dive into practical strategies, essential tests, and lessons learned from real-world failures — including a case study from CityWalk Beijing — to help you build smarter from the ground up.
Don’t miss it.
In the meantime, visit CASTO Corner, our growing library of field insights, technical tips, and industry case studies — all designed to help you navigate the evolving challenges of modern and themed construction.
